HC upholds 139 death penalties and life term for 146 in BDR mutiny

The High Court (HC) on Monday upheld the death sentence of 139 people among 152 condemned convicts in the Pilkhana BDR mutiny case.

Among the 152 condemned convicts, one died, four were acquitted and the death sentence of eight commuted to life term imprisonment.

Besides, the HC upheld the life term imprisonment of 146 convicts, among 160, acquitted 12 while two others died.

Earlier in the morning, the court concluded its observations with a seven-point recommendation in the case.

Among 256 other convicts, who were sentenced to different terms of imprisonment by a lower court, 182 got 10 years jail, eight seven years jail, two 13 years jail and four three years jail while two died and 29 were acquitted. Twenty-eight convicts did not file appeal against the lower court order.

Besides, among the 69 who were acquitted by the lower court earlier, 31 got life-term imprisonment, four seven years jail and appeals against acquittal of others were rejected.

With the HC verdict, a total of 139 people received death sentence, 185 life imprisonment and 196 different terms of jail while 45 were acquitted from charges and six convicts have died.

Justice Md Nazrul Islam Talukder read out the verdict in the afternoon after a three-member bench of himself, Justice Md Shawkat Hossain and Justice Md Abu Zafor Siddique concluded their observations in this regard.

In its recommendation, the High Court said the ‘Operation Dal Bhat’, introduced by the caretaker government, was a wrong decision. It also asked the government not to take ‘Operation Dal Bhat’ like programme in the future.

It also asked Bangladesh Rifles (BDR), now Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB), to maintain professional relations between officers and soldiers as per the BGB Act.

The HC also asked the authorities concerned to form probe committees to investigate why intelligence agency of BDR (now BGB) failed to know beforehand about such a big mutiny.

It also asked the government to pay the dues to the ‘BDR’ officials sacked following the carnage.

Justice Siddique observed that a vested quarter had wanted to destroy a skilled and trained force through the Pilkhana BDR mutiny to destablise the country and jeopardise its economic and social security.

He also described the BDR mutiny as an unprecedented incident in the world history. Later, the court postponed the reading out of the verdict till Monday morning.

On April 3 last, a three-member special HC bench, led by Justice Shawkat Hossain, kept the verdict pending as Curia Advisari Vult (CAV) after concluding the hearing on the appeals and the death reference.

A Dhaka court on November 5, 2013 sentenced 152 soldiers of the erstwhile Bangladesh Rifles and two civilians to death, and 161 others to life imprisonment for their involvement in the BDR mutiny.

A total of 257 appeals were filed with the High Court against the lower court verdict.

Seventy-four people, including 57 army officials, were killed in the BDR mutiny on February 25-26 in 2009 at the Pilkhana headquarters in Dhaka.

The paramilitary force was later renamed Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB).